The Brutalist, a film by Brady Corbet

Bauhaus meets Bathos. 

I enjoy long movies, if the length is justified. In the case of Brady Corbet’s The Brutalist, justification falls in the category of “I just wanted to,” not “The story needs this.” Laszlo Toth, the Brutalist architect subject of this pic, is portrayed as a junkie, homosexual, a Hungarian Jewish refugee whose best friend is a Black man, in America starting in 1947. Are these Corbet’s conceits, inserted to make Toth more relevant to our time, or more appealing, or sympathetic, or whatever? And, more to the point, what do any of those character traits have to do with Toth’s vision as a designer? 

This busy movie has 2 fully-realized characters: Adrien Brody’s Toth and Guy Pearce’s Harrison Van Buren. The rest are vehicles, sidekicks, and amplifiers of their passions. Brody plays a tormented outsider with creative vision, as he has before (think The Pianist). Guy Pearce gets to chew the scenery as a volatile man rich enough to force people to his will. He becomes Toth’s patron after a surprise by his children (transformation of his fusty library/ reading room into a modern space), which first enrages, then fascinates him. 

What the two men find in each other is a good listener. Van Buren waxes long-winded about his relationship with his mother, and with her parents who shunned her as an out-of-wedlock mother until in their old age they sought support. Then he pulled a cruel trick. He tells this story with the pride of a man who has bested a demon. Toth’s more circumspect, but he does talk about his artistry – the only part of this rambling film that interested me. 

Temper flare-ups from the clash between purity of vision and the realities of construction are performative. And why is Toth’s Black friend Gordon (Isaach de Bankole), who follows him from Philadelphia to sharing his bedroom at the Van Buren estate, accepted as his friend and equal? This relationship is not supported by the reality of 1950s America. Gordon, like other plot vehicles, serves a purpose: he introduces Toth to heroin. 

Even Toth’s Judaism feels like Corbet checking a box – Toth doesn’t mind designing Christian churches, nor does he seek friendship or comfort in the synagogue where he attends services. As an Orthodox Jew I didn’t see him refusing trayf foods – either his Jewish heritage matters to him or it doesn’t. 

The film is indulgent – I could take an hour out of its running time and you’d never miss it. My advice to Mr. Corbet is to go see Universal Language, a brilliantly subversive film by Matthew Rankin, in which you never know what’s going to happen next, but it makes its own sense when it does. In The Brutalist, I could see every plot twist coming a mile off. 

Adrien Brody, on the other hand, should play Samuel Beckett – if Tom Stoppard wrote the script, and Matthew Rankin directed, I’d go see that, whatever its run-time.

Creativity at the 47th Denver Film Festival

Reliably, Denver Film Fest screens bios and documentaries about artists. 2024 is no exception. My three favorites are: Swamp Dogg Gets his Pool Painted and Secret Mall Apartment and Two Artists Trying not to Kill Each Other – all different, all homages to the spirit of curiosity, insight, and collaboration. If you enjoy how creativity manifests in actions and relationships, these films will light you up! 

In brief, Swamp Dogg Gets his Pool Painted chronicles the life and musicality of Jerry Williams, Jr., an R&B singer and keyboardist who started performing in his teens and by the time he reached his early 20s, realized he needed a wilder name he could grow into for stage presence and edgy antics, and so became Swamp Dogg. Over the decades he toured, produced recordings for a wide range of artists, and wrote songs performed by blues, R&B, Southern rock and country singers. Meanwhile he was making his own records, and getting canned by one label after another. In his 70s he’s a widower, at home in The Valley – northeast LA – sharing his bachelor pad with Guitar Shorty and the young surprising multi-instrumentalist Moogstar, a man raised in the church who could play any instrument well and found healing from a harsh upbringing as a flamboyant and remarkable individual. And yes, the pool gets painted. 

Secret Mall Apartment is just what the title says: an empty space within the structure of the upscale Providence Mall in Providence, RI, discovered and inhabited by a group of artists displaced by development from the abandoned mill buildings across the river. RISD instructor Michael Townsend, who sparks ideas constantly, leads the group of artists who claim and transform this space. Along the way we learn about Townsend’s other projects, and who could not be moved by the transformational quality of his work? It’s a must-see! 

Two Artists Trying not to Kill Each Other is about the midlife marriage of Joel Meyerowitz, prolific and successful photographer, and Maggie Barrett, writer and artist who, while overshadowed by his fame, is his equal in their partnering of souls. We see some of their art, but what takes center stage is an honest mature relationship, in which both are able to say what they mean, criticize, and renew their deep affection. It’s a treatise in how to grow and maintain a loving adult relationship. 

And, it’s worth mentioning that in the toolbox of all these artists is a large portion of kindness. This is what we need these days, so you should see these films! Thank you for the opportunity to see them, DFF!